| 2024-04-20 16:00 | J45 | Sutton United |  | 2-2 |  | Crawley Town | Charlie Lakin 48', Oliver Sanderson 79'; Liam Kelly 42', Klaidi Lolos 90' | |
| 2024-04-06 16:00 | J43 | Sutton United | | 1-3 |  | Stockport County | Charlie Lakin 34' (P); Paddy Madden 3' 30' 45' | |
| 2024-04-01 16:00 | J42 | Sutton United | | 3-1 |  | Swindon Town | Charlie Lakin 9', Josh Coley 48', Harry Smith 70'; Paul Glatzel 90' | |
| 2024-03-23 16:00 | J40 | Sutton United | | 3-1 |  | Accrington Stanley | Harry Smith 16', Omar Sowunmi 68', Nino Adom-Malaki 74'; Jake Bickerstaff 85' | |
| 2024-03-09 16:00 | J37 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | Grimsby Town | Charlie Lakin 86' (P); Justin Obikwu 44' | |
| 2024-02-24 16:00 | J35 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | Colchester | Charlie Lakin 18'; Cameron McGeehan 7' | |
| 2024-02-13 20:45 | J33 | Sutton United | | 1-2 |  | Wrexham | Charlie Lakin 76'; Will Boyle 45', Elliot Lee 85' | |
| 2024-02-03 16:00 | J31 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | Doncaster Rovers | Craig Eastmond 73'; Joe Ironside 90' (P) | |
| 2024-01-30 20:45 | J21 | Sutton United | | 1-2 |  | Harrogate Town | Ryan Jackson 87'; Jack Muldoon 58' 75' | |
| 2024-01-13 16:00 | J28 | Sutton United | | 2-2 |  | Barrow AFC | Harry Beautyman 44' 53'; Ben Whitfield 36', Niall Canavan 73' | |
| 2024-01-01 16:00 | J26 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | Newport County | Tope Fadahunsi 90'; Shane McLoughlin 79' | |
| 2023-12-23 16:00 | J23 | Sutton United | | 0-2 |  | Mansfield Town | Stephen Quinn 25', Lucas Akins 75' | |
| 2023-12-02 16:00 | 2T | Sutton United | | 3-0 |  | Horsham FC | Dion Pereira 64' 74', Omari Patrick 89' | |
| 2023-11-28 20:45 | J20 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | Crewe Alexandra | Louis John 28'; Baker-Richardson 17' | |
| 2023-11-18 16:00 | J18 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | Tranmere Rovers | Ben Goodliffe 17' (c.s.c.), Louis John 88' | |
| 2023-11-04 16:00 | 1T | Sutton United | | 2-1 |  | AFC Fylde | Harry Smith 62' 67'; Jonathan Ustabasi 45' | |
| 2023-10-28 16:00 | J16 | Sutton United | | 2-1 |  | Bradford City | Josh Coley 4', Harry Beautyman 87'; Andy Cook 57' | |
| 2023-10-21 16:00 | J14 | Sutton United | | 2-3 |  | Morecambe | Harry Smith 45', Ben Goodliffe 62'; Michael Mellon 31' (P), Adam Mayor 45', Joel Senior 90' | |
| 2023-10-10 20:45 | Grp.B | Sutton United | | 0-0(5-4 pen.) | | Crawley Town | | |
| 2023-10-07 16:00 | J12 | Sutton United | | 4-0 |  | Walsall | Omari Patrick 6', Harry Smith 12' 37'; Joe Riley 27' (c.s.c.) | |
| 2023-10-03 20:45 | J11 | Sutton United | | 0-2 |  | Salford City | Matt Smith 54', Kelly N’Mai 65' | |
| 2023-09-23 16:00 | J9 | Sutton United | | 1-1 |  | MK Dons | Omar Sowunmi 37'; Alex Gilbey 53' | |
| 2023-09-19 20:45 | Grp.B | Sutton United | | 2-2(4-5 pen.) |  | Aston Villa U21 | Hisham Kasimu 79', Harry Beautyman 90'; Tommi O´Reilly 6' (P), Omari Kellyman 68' | |
| 2023-09-02 16:00 | J6 | Sutton United | | 0-1 |  | Forest Green Rovers | Harvey Bunker 63' | |
| 2023-08-19 16:00 | J4 | Sutton United | | 0-3 |  | AFC Wimbledon | Ryan Johnson 64', Harry Pell 80', James Tilley 86' | |
| 2023-08-15 20:45 | J3 | Sutton United | | 0-1 |  | Gillingham | Ashley Nadesan 10' | |
| 2023-08-08 20:45 | 1T | Sutton United | | 2-2(6-5 pen.) |  | Cambridge United | Harry Smith 38', Harry Beautyman 82' (P); Fejiri Okenabirhie 18' 60' (P) | |
| 2023-08-05 16:00 | J1 | Sutton United | | 5-1 |  | Notts County | Joe Kizzi 2', Omari Patrick 23' 51', Harry Beautyman 63', Harry Smith 78'; David McGoldrick 69' | |
