Plus large victoire à domicile | North American Soccer League 2017 | Puerto Rico FC | 3-0 | FC Edmonton |
Plus large victoire à l´extérieur | North American Soccer League 2016 | Miami FC | 0-1 | Puerto Rico FC |
| North American Soccer League 2016 | Ottawa Fury | 1-2 | Puerto Rico FC |
| North American Soccer League 2017 | Jacksonville Armada | 1-2 | Puerto Rico FC |
Plus large défaite à l´extérieur | North American Soccer League 2016 | New York Cosmos | 3-0 | Puerto Rico FC |
| North American Soccer League 2016 | Tampa Bay Rowdies | 3-0 | Puerto Rico FC |
| North American Soccer League 2016 | Indy Eleven | 3-0 | Puerto Rico FC |
| North American Soccer League 2017 | San Francisco Deltas | 3-0 | Puerto Rico FC |
Plus large défaite à domicile | North American Soccer League 2016 | Puerto Rico FC | 0-3 | Miami FC |
| North American Soccer League 2017 | Puerto Rico FC | 1-4 | New York Cosmos |
| North American Soccer League 2017 | Puerto Rico FC | 2-5 | New York Cosmos |